Home/Resources/Business
Business

How Business Owners Should Actually Pay Themselves

Taking money 'when it's available' isn't a compensation strategy. Here's how to build one that works.

5 min readApril 2025Michigan Society for Financial Education

One of the most overlooked financial decisions for business owners is how they get paid. Without a structured compensation system, personal finances become unpredictable, taxes get harder to manage, and long-term planning gets delayed.

Why This Matters More Than Most Owners Realize

Your business should support your life — not the other way around. But without a clear compensation structure, the line between business money and personal money blurs. Taxes become harder to estimate. Personal financial planning becomes impossible. And the stress of not knowing what you can 'afford' to take home becomes a constant background noise.

The most common approach — taking what's left over — creates more problems than it solves. It ties your personal financial stability to your business's month-to-month performance, which is inherently unpredictable.

A Better Approach: Three-Part Compensation

A structured compensation system has three components:

Base income: A consistent monthly amount that covers your personal living expenses. This should be set at a level your business can reliably sustain — not your best month, but a realistic average.

Profit distributions: Periodic bonuses taken when the business has excess cash above its operating needs and reserves. These are variable and tied to actual business performance.

Tax reserves: A separate account where you set aside a percentage of net profit for taxes. This is not your money to spend — it belongs to the IRS and Michigan Department of Treasury.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Only taking what's left over: This makes your personal finances a function of business volatility. A slow month means you don't get paid. A good month means you overspend.

Not planning for taxes: Self-employment and business income is not withheld at the source. If you don't set it aside proactively, the quarterly estimated tax bill will always feel like a surprise.

Mixing personal and business spending: Using your business account for personal expenses (or vice versa) creates bookkeeping nightmares, complicates your tax return, and can create legal liability issues depending on your entity structure.

What to Do This Week

Start by setting a baseline monthly income — an amount your business can consistently support. Open a separate tax reserve account and begin setting aside 25–30% of net profit. Review your last three months of business expenses to identify any personal spending that should be separated.

If you're unsure whether your current entity structure (sole proprietor, LLC, S-Corp) is optimized for how you're paying yourself, that's a conversation worth having with a CPA who specializes in business taxation.